- Glass Slipper
- Posts
- Golden Buzzer
Golden Buzzer
Ranking the five best wide receiver prospects in the 2025 NFL Draft.
Welcome to Glass Slipper! Sam Hubbard, I love you forever; please enjoy the show.
- Jacob Rhee
The NFL Draft is now only 50 days away. I ranked my top quarterbacks in the class last week, and now it’s time to do the same with the wide receivers. As a reminder, my pro comparison for each kid is not necessarily a projection of exactly how good they’ll become. I’m just giving you the NFL guy who consistently came to mind during my evaluation of the prospect. For this exercise, we’ll pretend that Travis Hunter is a wideout only; his cornerback value is not taken into consideration. Let’s get started.
Matthew Golden, Texas
NFL Comparison: Garrett Wilson
I never thought I’d be this high on a wide receiver who played two-thirds of his collegiate career in the AAC, had zero 1,000-yard seasons, and finished with exactly two catches on the biggest stage of his life. Here we are with Golden. I am hopelessly in love. Head over heels. I haven’t been this sure about a late first-rounder… ever?
The routes are sudden yet silky, the ball skills are fantastic, and he can flick on those 4.29 burners at any moment. This is Garrett Wilson reincarnated, and people still don’t see it.
4.29. Stamp it.
— Matthew Golden (@MatthewGolden_)
10:48 PM • Mar 1, 2025
Golden is going to make multiple Pro Bowls. I’ll try my best to spare you with the I-told-you-so antics when he’s battling for the Offensive Rookie of the Year.
Tetairoa McMillan, Arizona
NFL Comparison: Tee Higgins
If you haven’t watched Tet, he’s probably not the style of player that you think. It’s easy to assume that big dudes at the position are simply jump-ball artists, but there’s so much more to McMillan’s game. He actually does a lot of his work in short and intermediate areas, where his brilliant vision after the catch shines.
Tet does not drop passes, and I believe he’ll surprise some folks if he runs the 40 at the Big 12 Pro Day. I love how savvy he was as an improviser, when his buddy Noah Fifita was buying time. Match this kid with a quarterback that can move around - Bryce Young, perhaps - and you’ll have some magic.
T-Mac is everyone else’s consensus WR1 in the class. I disagree with the crowd, but I do like him as a productive, trustworthy option for the next decade.
Travis Hunter, Colorado
NFL Comparison: Malik Nabers
Every sports fan in existence is highly familiar with Travis, so there’s no need for a detailed breakdown or anything. At the very worst, he’s an electric No. 2 option that can take a slant to the house once in a while.
The WR version of Travis Hunter is easily one of the most underrated players in the draft. He's legit
— CJ (@cjfbscout)
6:07 PM • Feb 25, 2025
New England feels like the right fit to me. That franchise hasn’t employed a star receiver since Julian Edelman; let’s give Drake Maye his long-term running mate.
Emeka Egbuka, Ohio State
NFL Comparison: Chris Godwin
Emeka is the most bankable Ohio State offensive player of my lifetime. Period. This is what I wrote about him before the national championship.
The Buckeyes have 4th-and-3, with the fate of the universe hanging in the balance. You’re wearing the headset. Who’s getting the ball? Who do you trust the most? Close your eyes, and come up with a name.
We’re in agreement. It’s still Emeka Egbuka. He sat behind Garrett Wilson, Chris Olave, and Jaxon Smith-Njigba in Year 1. Then Marvin Harrison Jr. overshadowed him. Now Jeremiah Smith has stolen the spotlight. But when the moment arrives, there’s one player that feels like the safest option. The captain.
He blocks his tail off, loves the game, and will never create an ounce of drama. Egbuka is the smartest and most well-rounded wideout available. Whoever drafts my guy better take good care of him.
Jaylin Noel, Iowa State
NFL Comparison: Jayden Reed
Noel spent four seasons at Iowa State; his receptions, receiving yards, yards per catch, and touchdowns all went up every single year. That’s pretty rare stuff.
Not only did he post a 4.39 at the combine, but he also won the vertical, broad jump, and bench press crowns for the position group.
Jaylin Noel at the NFL Combine:
4.39s 40-yard dash
1.51s 10-yard split
41.5" vertical jump
11'2" broad jump
6.82s 3-cone drill
4.17s 20-yard shuffleTop-ten in all drills among wideouts.
— StatMuse Football (@statmusefb)
1:57 PM • Mar 2, 2025
Jaylin - though only 5-foot-10 - is a freak athlete who cares about the right things. I see him enjoying a lengthy and successful NFL career.
Missed the Cut
Jayden Higgins, Iowa State
Xavier Restrepo, Miami
Luther Burden III, Missouri
Tre Harris III, Ole Miss
Elic Ayomanor, Stanford
Our friend Jaylin Noel has a Cyclone buddy who’s pretty lethal in his own right. Higgins was a two-star recruit, and he might wind up being a top-50 pick. Meanwhile, Restrepo is just always wide open. Facing ACC defenses helped, but I do think he has some impressive feel in the slot.
No, I did not forget about Luther Burden. I just absolutely despise his body language when things aren’t going his way. Harris was trying to barge into Heisman conversations at one point last season, but I don’t love the lack of top-end speed on a dude who relies so heavily on deep shots. Though I certainly hope Ayomanor stays healthy, his injury history terrifies me.
Pressroom
We didn’t take him in the second round just to be a third-string quarterback.
Reply